University of Medicine and Health Sciences
    UMHS-logo
    Virtual Tour
    Apply Now

    Optometrist vs Ophthalmologist vs Optician- Choosing the right Eye care professional

    Posted by Callie Torres
    March 13, 2021

    When looking for an Eye care professional, there are three different types of practitioners that one may come upon. They differ in educational requirements, scope of practice, salary and services provided. In this article we detail the similarities and differences in each of these eye care specialists, sometimes referred to as the 3 "O's" of eye-care. We also compare and contrast an Optometrist vs Ophthalmologist vs Optician.

    Ophthalmology - What is an Ophthalmologist and what do they do?

    An Ophthalmologist is a highly skilled Allopathic medicine or Osteopathy trained Physician specializing in eye care and the medical field of Ophthalmology. The level of training Opthalmologists undergo allows them to treat all eye conditions. However, most primarily work with  the medical and surgical treatment of the eye and ocular Adnexa. This includes the Orbit, Conjunctiva, Sclera, Eyelids, Eyebrows, Eyelashes, Lacrimal Gland and Drainage Apparatus.

    What Eye Care Services Do They Provide?

    An ophthalmologist specializes in medically treating the eye, orbit, and visual systems. In addition to operating, ophthalmologists may provide vision checks, treat eye infections with antibiotics, and provide a glasses and/or contact prescription. An ophthalmologist commonly splits their time between the eye clinic and the operating room. In clinic, they can diagnose and treat eye health diseases and use lasers to correct eye conditions in addition to performing vision checks. In the operating room, ophthalmologists can perform glaucoma surgery, cataract surgery, LASIK surgery, refractive surgery to correct vision, correct tear duct infections or malformations, repair damaged retinas, corneal transplantation, and manage eye traumas.

    The main duties of an Ophthalmologist include:

    • providing vision services, such as eye care exams
    • diagnosing and treating eye health conditions such as glaucoma, iritis, macular degeneration  and cataracts
    • performing surgical intervention for vision care conditions such as trauma, glaucoma, lazy eye correction, and cataract surgery with lens implant
    • performing in-office eye care procedures such as LASIK and other laser eye surgeries for vision correction

     

    Ophthamologist performing surgery

     

    Eye Doctor at a slit lamp

     

    What are the educational requirements to become Ophthalmologists?

    The educational health program required to become an ophthalmologist is very rigorous. First, one must complete a college bachelor’s degree. There is not a specific degree required for admission to medical school although, many students complete a biology or chemistry degree. This is followed by obtaining a medical degree from either an Osteopathic Medical Program (D.O. degree) or an Allopathic Medical program (M.D. degree) which takes four years to complete. Upon graduation, students are officially a Doctor but their training is not yet complete. After medical school, one must match into an ophthalmology residency training program or a preliminary/transitional year. Ophthalmology residency lasts three years but is preceded by an intern or transitional year of training. After ophthalmology residency, individuals have the option of completing a fellowship in a subspecialty field of study. Most ophthalmology fellowships are one to two years and allow individuals to further specialize into a specific portion of ophthalmology.

    What is average for an Ophthamologist salary?

    There are many sources that give an estimate of the average salary for an Ophthalmologist. In our opinion the data gathered by Medscape is the most accurate. Accordingly, they reported that in 2019 the average salary for an Ophthalmologist is  $366,000 per year. This puts an Ophthalmology trained specialist at above the average pay for a physician.

    What is the Job Outlook for Ophthalmologists?

    According to The American Academy of Ophthalmology, there are roughly 27,500 active ophthalmologists in the US as of 2018. Almost 50% of these ophthalmology physicians are over the age of 55, meaning there could be a shortage of ophthalmologists when they retire. Additionally, the Bureau of Labor Statistics projects the ophthalmologist job market to increase by 13% through 2026.

    Optometry - What is an Optometrist and what do these eye doctors do?

    An Optometrist is an eye care health specialist that focuses on treating the eye, orbit, and visual systems. Optometrists medically manage many eye care disorders and diseases that can affect a patient's vision.

    What Eye Care Services Do Optometrists Provide?

    An optometrist also specializes in treating the health of the eye, orbit, and visual systems. Optometrists primarily provide vision health care, perform routine comprehensive eye exam and vision checks, and provide a prescription for contacts and glasses. However, unlike ophthalmologists, optometrists do not perform major eye surgeries such as cataract surgery. Instead, optometrists provide non-surgical medical health care of diseases and conditions that affect the eye. In some states, optometrists are also able to medically perform laser procedures and other minor ocular surgical procedures although this is not common.

    The main duties of an Optometrist include:

    • providing vision services, such as eye care exams, vision therapy and vision tests
    • prescribing eye glasses, contact lenses, and performing specialty contact lens fitting
    • monitoring eye conditions associated with systemic diseases such as diabetes
    • managing medical eye health care conditions such as glaucoma, iritis, dry eye and cataracts
    • prescribe medication to treat eye disease such as conjuntivitis (also known as red eye or pink eye)

      Female Optometrist with patient doing an eye health exam

       

      eye examination with a phoropter

       

    What are the educational requirements to become an Optometrist?

    The education required to become an optometrist is also very arduous. First, a bachelor's degree must be completed. Similar to medical school, optometry school does not require a specific type of degree. Instead, pre-requisite courses must be completed prior to application to optometry school. Once accepted to optometry school, students spend four years studying optometry. Following graduation from optometry school, individuals obtain a Doctor of Optometry degree which is abbreviated as OD. Optometrists are indeed Doctors, but are not considered to be a medical doctor or physician. 

    What is average for an Optometrist salary?

    There are many sources that provide earning estimates for Optometrists. Salary.com shows a wide range of income levels between $100,000 to $150,000. If we look at data collected by the US Bureau Of Labor Statistics the median annual wage for optometric eye doctors in May 2019 was $115, 250.

    What is the Job Outlook for Optometrists?

    According to the U.S. Bureau of Labor Statistics, the job of Optometrist is expected to grow by 4% through 2029. This is on par with the average job growth rate in the United States. There are currently an estimated 44,000 practicing optometrists with an estimated increase of 1,900 new optometrists by 2029. Many vision problems tend to occur later on in life, and an aging general population will most likely require more optometrists to take care of the increasing vision conditions.

    What is an Optician and what do they do?

    An Optician in one of the three O's in the eyecare field and is a specialist who primarily works with adjusting eye glasses, lenses, sunglasses, and contacts. Opticians are not doctors and cannot give eye exams or diagnose medical eye problems such as dry eye.

    What is the scope of practice and services they provide?

    The scope of practice for an Optician will vary from one State to another depending upon the laws that govern the practice of Opticianry in that State.  There has been political movements by Optician societies to try and get State laws changed to allow them to perform the procedure to check the prescription needed for a persons eyeglasses, called a refraction, independent of a supervising Optometrist or Ophthalmologist.  Currently, we know of no State laws that allow this though. 

    The primary duties of an optician include:

    • Adjusting and repairing eyeglass frames
    • Assisting patients in selecting eyeglass lenses and sunglasses
    • Working with patients to select eyeglass frames
    • Checking eyeglass lens prescriptions
    optician helping a patient choose eyeglasses

     

    optician in an optical lab

     

    What are the educational requirements to become an Optician?

    Currently, the educational requirement to become an Optician varies from state to state. In some states, Opticians must be licensed by the State's Department of Professional Regulation or a similar entity. In other states there are no requirements to become an Optician and licensure is not needed. There are also 1 to 2 year degrees offered by many different colleges, junior colleges and universities culminating in an associates degree for those pursuing a more formal educational path.

    What is the average salary for an Optician?

    The average optician's salary varies greatly depending upon the source viewed. As mentioned previously, some states require licensing in order to work as an Optician. Licenced opticians may be paid a higher salary than non-licensed opticians. The most accurate sources estimate an Optician's average pay between $37,000 and $47,000 per year.

    COVID-19 impact on Eye Care

    Since the beginning of 2020, COVID-19 has had a huge impact on jobs nationwide. Physicians and other healthcare related jobs are no exception. Overall, medical practices in the U.S. report a fifty-five percent decrease in revenue and a sixty percent decrease in average patient volume since the beginning of the COVID-19 crisis. Due to this drastic decrease in revenue, medical practices and hospitals have furloughed and laid off employees including 43,000 healthcare workers in March 2020 alone. Nine percent of independent medical practices state they have at least temporarily closed their practices. As social distancing guidelines remain in effect, remote patient engagement has soared and increased by an astounding two hundred twenty five percent.

    Similar to other surgical specialties, during the height of the pandemic many ophthalmologic surgeries were postponed. When hospitals and surgical centers did open back up, urgent surgeries were prioritized. Patients required a negative COVID-19 test result prior to ophthalmology surgery. Ophthalmologists and staff required additional personal protective equipment and extra sanitization steps in the operating room. Ophthalmology clinics were particularly affected, with some studies showing that ophthalmology suffered the greatest decline in patient visits compared to other medical specialties. Some ophthalmology and optometry clinics were forced to temporarily or even permanently close. However as the pandemic continued, ophthalmology and optometry clinics shifted to using telemedicine. According to one survey published by the American Association of Ophthalmology, over 40% of physician respondents stated that telephone calls were the primary means of conducting patient visits in July of 2020. Optometry practices were similarly affected with many practices having up to a 91% decrease in vision exams performed during early 2020. Although patient visits are slowly increasing, their numbers are nowhere near where they were in previous years.

    What is the difference between an Optometrist and an Ophthalmologist?

    Optometrists and Ophthalmologists are both doctors that work to treat health conditions that affect the eye and vision. The main differences between the two are that an ophthalmologist graduates from medical school and can perform surgery and complicated procedures, while an optometrist graduates from optometry school and mainly perform non surgerical services. For routine eye examintations, seeing an Optometrist for care is the correct choice.. 

    Posted by Callie Torres

    Callie Torres is a published author and Lieutenant In the United States Air Force. With a Bachelors's and Masters's degree in Biology, she has received multiple grants and loves writing about modern-day medicine.

    Topics: Feature Medical Practice

    Add a comment 

    Explore UMHS's campus in St. Kitts. Start your 360 degree virtual campus tour.